|
A Great Race
in Harlem
Will "Hiphop Minister" Conrad Muhammad Go from
N.O.I. to G.O.P.?
Conrad Muhammad: Hey, good brother, whats happening? Whats going on, man?
Man on 125th St.: Im alright, how you doin?
CM: Its good to see you. Hows your family doing? They good? Hows Tony?
M125: Hes great.
CM: You know Im running for Congress, right?
M125: Congress?
CM: Did you hear about it?
M125: You wanna be a politician?
CM: I think its time that a good strong brother gets into the process, you dig?
M125: Its all good.
CM: Now, you know me, I havent changed.
M125: Dont get in there and sell out.
CM: I wont do that. Ill be the same man Ive always been. And you know it. And Im coming in smokin, just like that.
M125: Dont sell out, man, dont sell out. The devil is busy.
CM: If I sell out, you come and get me.
M125: Im comin to get you, yo.
Conrad Muhammad is the fastest walker in Harlem. The late-afternoon sidewalks are sweltering, but hes wearing a suit and tie, keeping a rush-hour pace. Everyone else is doing that unhurried summer shuffle, or else theyre stationary, under trees in folding chairs. The former Nation of Islam minister greets them allheartily, many by name. When someone replies with more than a greeting, he turns on his heel without breaking stride to face him. The new perspective might yield a view of someone else he wants to approach, in which case: zip. Its like trying to follow a bumblebee.
"This community needs someone with young legs, who can walk up and down the streets of this district and provide leadership to the people," is the first thing he tells me. He says he walks the streets of Harlem every day. I find out later that by "every day" he actually means every day hes not down in Baltimorewhere he was until recently director of outreach for a churchor up in Mount Vernon, where hes employed as administrator of a $3 million grant for city youth programs. There was also some time at Harvard. He did a lot of walking and greeting as part of his old job, though. Today, the focus is on what hed like to be his nextU.S. congressman from the 15th Districtand its clear enough that hes no carpetbagger.
He has a youthful face to go with his young legs. Hes a natural speaker, with skills sharpened by a decade of preaching and a mini-career in radio, and hes not a bad listener, either. People in Harlem know who he is. To some, no doubt, hes just that fast-walking guy with the suit, but Muhammad wouldnt have conducted an interview while working Harlems streets if the routine didnt make him appear widely respected. It does. The question is, Is he serious? His generational peer across the Hudson, Cory Booker, held political office and enjoyed outside as well as grassroots support, yet he failed to wrest power from Newarks Mayor Sharpe James. Conrad Muhammad may be down with the regular folks, and they might be tired of the old dandy in office, but a demonstration of that is not necessarily as impressive as a campaign plan, some experienced strategists and a volunteer team might have been. Those are not things he has to show, today at least.
Muhammads most intense period of communication with the people of Harlem was plenty serious. He was a successor to Malcolm X, heading the Nation of Islams mosque No. 7. Many people still address him as Minister, even though he doffed his bowtie five years ago. A phantom association with the Nation may be a boon to the candidates popularity along Malcolm X Blvd., but its also likely to be the main obstacle between Muhammad and his goal. Thats because the easiest way to acquire funding to oppose Democrat Charles Rangel, whos held the House of Representatives 15th District seat since 1970, would be as a Republican. And the local G.O.P. is cool on Conrad. The party has said the problem is that hes a registered Democrat. Muhammad doesnt buy it.
"My whole career has been talking about self-sufficiency, the African-American people taking their own destiny into their hands," he says. He points out that hes a free-marketer, that his message is strong on traditional values and that the local G.O.P. regularly endorses candidates far to the left of him. His post-N.O.I. work as "The Hiphop Minister" was undisguised conservative activism. Furthermore, he adds, the Republicans put Rangel on their line in several of his 16 successful races. Calling the issue of his party affiliation "a smokescreen, a red herring," he says he and the Republican leadership "shouldnt even be arguing over this. We should be focused on getting the seat."
Conrad Muhammad: Hey, brother, how are you? You know Im running for Congress?
Jamaican Man on Lenox Ave.: Yes I do. I heard it.
CM: I need your help.
JM: You Democrat or Republican?
CM: Ah, Im running as a Republican.
JM: Thats not going to work.
CM: Listen to me: I am a Democrat, but I may have to run as a Republican.
JM: Its not going to work.
CM: Remember Bloomberg was a Democrat all his life. He had to run as a Republican because the system
JM: You dont want anything to do with that.
CM: You dont like the brother.
JM: Nah, I really dont.
CM: I have not liked him in the past, but sometimesyou see, we got too many people in one club. We got to be in both parties.
JM: They not gon change, boss.
CM Let me ask you a question: Are you a betting man at all?
JM: Huh?
CM: Do you betare you a betting man?
JM: Yeah.
CM: You ever go to the racetrack?
JM: Oh yes.
CM: When you go to the racetrack, how manydo you bet on one horse, or do you spread your money around?
JM: Sometimes three, because sometimes I play the trifecta.
CM: Thats what Im saying. In politics you gotta do the same thing. You cant have all Democrats. You gotta have some Democrats and some Republicans.
JM: You have to look at the constituency, you know what Im saying? These people are not gon change that easily. You have to come up with something real good for them to do that. Im telling you. Get with the hiphop crowd and the old folks and stay right in the middle.
CM: I know what youre saying.
JM: And you will do it, trust me.
CM: And I can count on your vote?
JM: [Makes face indicating that hes not ready to vote Republican]
CM: [Laughing] Okay, okay.
Muhammad is 37, divorced, the father of three. His children reside primarily with their mother in Bethesda, MD, though Conrad shares custody. Despite his comfort in Harlem, his speaking voice is obviously that of a non-native New Yorker. He grew up in St. Louis and Washington, DC, middle-class and Christian. He came to politics and black nationalism simultaneously, while an undergrad at the University of Pennsylvania, working on Jesse Jacksons 1984 presidential campaign. "I became discouraged and almost bitter against the political process, because I felt that he was disrespected," he recalls, then adds, "but that was in my immaturity."
That same year, his 19th, Muhammad joined the Nation of Islam. "I had a lot of faith in the Nation, pretty much because of the message of self-reliance, family values, hard work, discipline and clean living," he says. Though Muhammad doesnt speak of it, his rise to the top of the local N.O.I. hierarchy suggests that in his 20s he was extremely effective at communicating the Nations messagewhich, Nation detractors are quick to point out, has included anti-Jewish and anti-American rhetoric. He was 32 when he and the Nation parted ways.
"I just became frustrated with the direction of the movement," he says. "I believe that as African-Americans we can be critical of this country, but we have to embrace our American-ness, and we have to embrace the process. Ive really grown to believe that we have the best political system in the world. Ive grown to appreciate democracy. And I think the Nation is challenged to embrace those ideas. You may not like the way things are, but you have a right to say it, and in a lot of countries you dont."
One of the stops on Muhammads greeting tour is Harlem Underground, a custom hat and t-shirt store off 125th St. Outside, we run into Carl Redding, proprietor and chef of the soul-food restaurant Amy Ruths. Muhammad introduces us, and I ask Redding if hes ever voted Republican. He replies that he has, three times in factfor Reagan, Pataki and Bloomberg. Muhammad is engaged in another conversation at the moment, so I follow Redding into Harlem Underground, and Muhammad soon enters as well, teasing me about "diving for the air conditioning."
The candidate, who had been more than an hour late for our interview, neglected to mention that it would be conducted while he worked the streets. Reddings suggestion that Muhammad purchase an embroidered "Conrad for Congress" cap at Harlem Underground is what allows an uninterrupted question-and-answer session to take place. While the hat is being embroidered, hes stuck. If keeping a reporter moving shows solid political instincts, Muhammads performance when literally cornered in Harlem Underground indicated acumen extending still further beyond his ability to connect with a crowd. Which is to say, he was amiably evasive, saying things like, "I absolutely support the concept of gun control."
Heres the distilled version of Conrad Muhammad on the issues: Hes for the war and "very supportive" of President Bushs handling of it so far. But hes "concerned" about Ashcroft "overreaching" on civil liberties. Hes also with the President on welfare, particularly his approach to "talking about the importance of marriage with regard to welfare." Hes against discrimination based on sexual orientation, but would vote "no" on a civil unions bill. Hes pro-life except in cases of rape, incest or life-of-the-mother-at-stake. And he believes that the Constitution guarantees the right to bear arms. All of these he frames in terms of values. He says he wants a society ethical enough that abortions are rare and citizens feel safe without guns.
In summary, Muhammad gives a statement that wouldnt sound off-key at a Republican National Convention: "Im a religious man. I think values are important. Ive worked in the community a long time. And I know that no amount of government money can change this community if we dont have a strong family value." The only hitch is he refuses to indicate from which religion hes currently drawing his values. "We got em all here, and I intend to serve all constituencies," he demurs. "Im a man of faith, and well leave it at that."
The New York Sun reported in its July 5-7 issue that Muhammad plans to convert back to Christianity. According to the Suns Errol Louis, on a Sunday near the end of June, Muhammad stood alongside Rev. Calvin Butts at Harlems Abyssinian Baptist Church and told the assembled that "at some point in the future" he will retake his birth name, Conrad Tillard.
New York Post columnist Robert A. George is someone who thinks Muhammad could, with Republican Party support, unseat Rangel. In a scathing June 3 editorial (headlined "The Grand Old Stupid Party?"), he chided Assemblyman John Ravitz, Manhattan Republican Party chairman, for giving Muhammad the brush-off. George quoted Ravitz saying that the former minister should start on the path to G.O.P. acceptance by campaigning in Harlem for Gov. Patakis reelection.
Muhammad tells me hed be happy to do just that. "Ive endorsed him," he says. "More has happened in this community under George Pataki and Secretary of State Randy Daniels than had happened for a long time." Also, he adds, "I think [Pataki] has done a good deal to help repeal the Rockefeller Drug Laws, which hurt a lot of African-American young people. Young peoples lives have been thrown away, and Cuomo didnt do anything about it."
A more likely scenario involves Muhammad devoting the summer of 2002 to campaigning for himself. Thats the case even though the local G.O.P.even before Georges Post editorial saw printendorsed Independence Party candidate Jessie Fields for Congress from the 15th. (Fields might be as unlikely a Republican endorsee as Muhammad, or Rangel for that matter. Shes a Harlem doctor who runs single-issue campaigns about healthcare.) Only hours before our interview, Assemblyman Ravitz rescheduled a meeting with Muhammad that had been planned for the following day. The candidate said he was taking steps to enact Plan B: challenging Rangel in the Democratic primary instead. That would be a David-vs.-Goliath struggle, to say the leastfighting within a party against its 32-year incumbentbut, regardless, his Democratic petition drive is already under way. His only hope to get on the Republican line is to convince Ravitz and the other G.O.P. leaders to make a second endorsement and force a G.O.P. primary against Fields.
Assemblyman Ravitz says thats not going to happen. Reached via telephone, he said a primary would "defeat the purpose" of the Fields endorsement, and that " our number-one goal should be to support one candidate against an entrenched incumbent like Congressman Rangel." He refuted the notion that Fields is less likely than Muhammad to win, calling it "a self-fulfilling prophecy." Then he lauded the Independence Party candidate and her fellow endorsees in a way that rather pointedly echoed Muhammads portrayal of himself. "What Im doing," said Ravitz, "is finding candidates to run for assembly, for the state Senate and for Congress in Harlem, who really have a community resume, that arent just people who we decided, Hey, itd be a great idea for you to run for office. These are people who have invested their life, their time and energy into so many different parts of their community that they want to take things to the next level and run for office."
Ravitz said there are reasons why the G.O.P. is wary of Muhammad, and none of them are secret. Directing me to the Anti-Defamation Leagues website for specifics, he says, "Conrad knows about the problems with some of the things that hes said in the past I believe hes going to have to address and deal with [them]. I think that all of us who are in public life have to be held accountable for our words, and there are a lot of things that Conrad still needs to work withpeople who are still feeling very hurt about some of those comments." Its possible that some of those people have Conrad Muhammad confused with the late Khalid Muhammad, however. A 1996 ADL press release quotes Conrad Muhammad calling Jews "bloodsuckers" and Christianity "a dirty religion," but his search hits dont compare to those of the controversy-seeking Khalid, who was fired from his N.O.I. leadership job in 1994 and picked a fight with NYPD cops at the Million Youth March four years later.
Whether as Conrad Muhammad (R) or as Conrad Tillard (D), or vice versa, he plans to go for it. He believes that enough of Harlem wants to send him to Washington.
Muhammad says the energy and creativity of his campaign will resonate with the hiphop generation, with which he has a lot of experience. After he left the Nation, Muhammad founded A Movement for C.H.H.A.N.G.E. ("Conscious Hip Hop Activism Necessary for Global Empowerment") and started calling himself "The Hiphop Minister." He decried the mid-90s flood of lyrics portraying black communities as nests of degeneracy, and publicly shamed the businessmen who grew from rich to richer off them. That earned Muhammad the ire of Def Jams founding executive, Russell Simmons, but no artists went on record lashing out at him. Some of them, perhaps, really were shamed.
Today, Muhammad characterizes C.H.H.A.N.G.E.s "Campaign for Dignity" as more of an esthetics campaign than a political one. "I think my challenge to [rappers] was a critical challenge," he says. "We used to talk about white men in Hollywood that put out images of people in our community as pimps and prostitutes. Now Im trying to show these young people: Now you are in the position that you control the imagery and you have to be sensitive to that. You are in power nowwhat are you going to do with it? You cant say you love the hood, and see the kids in the hood listening to your music and going to jail or dying, and not feel some responsibility."
He says he achieved the authority to preach to hiphop artists by being there when they needed him. Men who grew up in communities where the Nation was a stable presence generally perceive it to be righteous, and when he was a minister Muhammad mediated between warring rap factions more than once. He settled a dispute between A Tribe Called Quest and Wrecks-N-Effect with one meeting. He also intervened in the East-West coastal feudless successfully, sadly. "I saw Puffy shed tears up here when Suge Knight was coming down on him," he recalls. Muhammad says he didnt feel a need to speak up when artists with underworld experience started rapping about it, but "I knew that some of the guys who were doing it were not from a criminal background Ive seen these men offstage, and said to them, I know you. You may project a certain image, but this is your brother saying to you its gone too farstop it."
Its difficult to think of another link, besides the Nation of Islam and its offshoots, between conservative ethics and raps gangsta subculture. An inner-city Republican who brings to the table the N.O.I.s success at instilling a sense of responsibility in antisocial young men without the organizations negative baggage would seem, at least on paper, to be a strong candidate. After all, the hiphop generation is bound to elect someone somewhere, eventually. Theoretically, Muhammads youth angle could give the G.O.P. an edge on issues that are of perennial concern to black New Yorkers, such as education and crime. The Republicans already win on taxes and the war. How close is the reality of Conrad Muhammad to this idealized ghetto-G.O.P. candidate? Maybe it makes more sense to ask how close the G.O.P. has ever gotten to Conrad Muhammad.
After our mano-a-mano session, still in Harlem Underground, Muhammad rejoins Carl Redding, the Reagan-supporting restaurateur. He tells me Redding used to work with Rev. Al Sharpton. We discuss national politics, and Redding, by way of explaining how the Clinton years changed his view of the Republican Party for the worse, recounts a run-in with the current president. "Bush came to Harlem and I took a picture with him. They were courting me to work on his campaign handling the African-American clergy. This was in January [2000]. I thought hard about it. They offered me six figures. I couldnt do it," he says.
"Now," offers Muhammad, "as George W. Bush and Gov. Pataki are talking about inclusion, its time for a paradigm shift to take place." He says that Democratic candidates receiving up to and beyond 90 percent of the African-American vote is not in African-American peoples interest. To Muhammad, its realistic to aim for a 70-30 split. He explains, "Its not about why we should vote for Republicans. The question is, Why shouldnt we place ourselves in that party and leverage our influence in both parties? Fifty-fifty is not realistic. But 70-30 is, I think, a winning formula for the African-American community. Because it makes our 70 percent in the Democratic Party a stronger 70 percent, [because] the fact of 30 percent of us leaving and going to the Republican Party would make Democrats work harder for the numbers they do have, and that critical 30 percent in the Republican Party would let them know that were a force they have to reckon with."
As for the rabid anti-Republicanism of supposedly nonpartisan African-American leaders, Muhammad says, "Its immoral in a sense, because our leaders have betrayed us. Our political leaders have, essentially, a vested interest in delivering black bodies to the Democratic Party. Almost like a slave trade. And, so, what it has done is, it has not allowed our community to engage in the free market of politics. If theres only one drycleaners on 125th St., chances are youre going to get bad service [there]. Its a captive marketyou dont have anywhere else to go. But let two or three drycleaners open up. Competition is good in business, its also good in politics."
Conrad Muhammad: How are you ladies today?
Ladies One and Two outside of Pentecostal Church: Fine.
CM: Did you know Im running for Congress?
L1 and L2: [Smile and nod]
CM: I sure could use your help. Im running against a great man but hes just been there too long. I think its time for him to let a young man go forward, dont you think so?
L1 and L2: [Smile and nod]
Adam Heimlich: What do you think of Charlie Rangel?
L1: Hes a wonderful man.
L2: Hes a wonderful person. Hes done an extensive job. And continues to do an extensive job. However, as you say, for a young man to put forth his efforts
CM: I told this gentleman right herein this community we respect our elders. I would never disrespect Congressman Rangel.
L2: Oh no, never.
CM: You dont disrespect a bridge
L2: that brought you over.
CM: Thats what my grandmother taught me. But its time for a new generation of leadership to step forward.
Leaving Harlem Underground, Conrad Muhammad leads me to the Harlem U.S.A. retail complex, which opened two years ago and is the keystone of Upper Manhattans participation in the federal "empowerment zone" revitalization plan. We stand across 125th St. from the Disney Store, the HMV record store and the Magic Johnson movie theater, while Muhammad points out another record store, Record Shack, on the next block east of the shopping center.
"Thats a business thats been in this community for 30 years," says Muhammad of Record Shack. "A small business, and of course Republicans support small businesses, right? Why would an empowerment zone not give moneys to that store owner, whos been here through good times and bad, and then open up an HMV a few doors down, to drive this man out of business? What kind of community development and leadership is that? It couldnt possibly have been thought through! Theres no clearer metaphor for why Im running than this right here. This man has committed 30 years to this community."
The man Muhammad refers to is Record Shack owner Sikhulu Shange. He and his store have an interesting history. They were the linchpin of the 1995 controversy that got out of control and ended with the massacre at Freddies Fashion Mart. It started when Record Shack faced eviction, and ended when a man presumed to be a former street vendor whod been forced out by revitalization efforts (a development that Shange, reportedly, had supported) entered Freddies with a gun and a bottle of lighter fluid and committed mass murder.
Muhammad doesnt mention the incident. Instead, he asks me to interview Shange. The deep-voiced man makes an eloquent complaint about the local governments failure to involve him in the changes on 125th St. He seems to be against the empowerment zone as a matter of anticorporate principle, but allows that "Even if they brought these companies into the community, they should have empowered us to compete."
The encounter with Shange rings a little contradictory, coming so closely on the heels of Muhammads allegory about competition in drycleaning. Similarly, some hot air is let out of his grand statement about the limitations of what government money can do for the African-American community when he tells a young mother that he supports reparations for slavery. On Rangel, too, Muhammads efforts to be the word on the street made flesh have him occasionally spinning in two directions at once.
Walking past the 125th St. building that houses Bill Clintons office, Muhammad tells me that rent on the buildings across the street doubled or tripled the day the former president moved in. He said, "And Rangel invited him in! Now what kind of leadership is that? Youve got to have a view of what the economic consequences are. It got the Congressman good media, but it really wasnt a good thing for the district. At the end of the day, thats exploitation. I believe in the free market, but the political leadership shouldnt speed up the process of people being dispossessed, people being priced out. Thats not leadership."
In Newark earlier this year, four-term incumbent Sharpe James portrayed Cory Booker as an infiltrator, representing interests antithetical to those of the citys working poor. The Mayor seemed to have some success at making this characterization stick, even though at the time of the election Booker resided in a Newark housing project, as he did throughout his term as city councilman. The tactics Democratic incumbents tend to use in tight contests against upstarts (Jesse Jackson, for whom Booker volunteered in 88, stopped by Newark to call the challenger "a wolf in sheeps clothing") is something Muhammad has been paying attention to. "They brought in all kinds of Democratic leaders," he says of James campaign. "But even with all they said about [Booker], he still got almost 50 percent of the vote. So what that says to me is that the people are ready for a change. The leadership, obviously, isnt, because they have a vested interest," he says.
"But they cant say that about me in Harlem," Muhammad continues. "Because this is where I cut my teeth. They saw me out here. Id like to see Congressman Rangel say that Im an outsider."
And what if he plays dirtier than that, and uses Muhammads N.O.I. background to paint a media portrait of him as a hatemongering, anti-American radical?
"Hes not a bad guy," Muhammad replies. "But I think his style of leadership has served its purpose, and the district needs new energy.
For Muhammad to challenge Rangel and not expect the Congressman to play hardball smacks of naivete. If he doesnt drag you into the mud, I suggest, it means youre not a threat.
"No," counters Muhammad, "I think what it means is he knows he couldnt get away with it, politically, in this community. If he did that, Id go straight to Washington on a first-class ticket. The people in this district will not let the media tell them who their leaders should be. And if he tries to paint me as a negative character, people will rally to my side."
Conrad Muhammad: How you doing?, hows it going? Is it your brother that shoots for the Amsterdam News?
Man 1 at Vendors Table: Nah nah, youre talking about [name deleted].
CM: You look just like him! Thats not your brother?
M1: Nah, thats not my brother. Were good friends.
CM: Well how you doin?
M1: Im fine.
CM: Good to see you. You know Im running, right?
Man 2 at Vendors Table: You running against Charlie? You gonna bang Charlie in the head?
CM: Dont you think?
M2: Man, Charlie been rolling too long. Too long.
Man 3 at Vendors Table: Sipping on too many cocktails. Sold out the empowerment zone! Cmon.
CM [to reporter]: You see? The only things Im telling you are what the people are saying to me. I have never met this man. And he just told you exactly what I was just
M3: Well, you know Charlies experienced. You better be ready!
Adam Heimlich: Are you ready to pull that "Republican" lever to get this man in and Charlie out?
M3: Well, he gotta walk the walk, and then he gotta go straight up with Charlie. I want to see some verbal uppercuts, left-crosses and all that.
M1: The Republicans endorse him every time, anyway.
CM [to reporter]: What did I just tell you? See, dont ask me why Im running as a Republican. He ran as a Republican for 30 years!
M2: Thats right. And he kicks people off the ballot.
M3: Which you gon learn real well!
CM: Believe me, were ready for it.
Conrad Muhammad got into Harvard to pursue two masters degreesone at the School of Divinity, and another at the Kennedy School, in public administration. It was in a class for the latter that he read Bernard Cricks In Defense of Politics, which argues that the democratic process, disappointing as it tends to be, represents the most pragmatic alternative to government by force. Muhammad says Cricks book helped him complete his break with the Nation of Islams opinion of what it means to work within the American system. Cricks utilitarian perspective seems to have also influenced his somewhat unorthodox view of the Republican Party.
Hes currently on hiatus from both Harvard programs. When he applied, he says, Rangel wrote him a recommendation. "A very strong letter," says Muhammad. Another connection between the Congressman and his challenger-to-be, according to Muhammad, is that Rangel is a major shareholder in WBLS, the radio station that broadcast the Hiphop Ministers hour-long Sunday Night Live community-issues program for five years, ending in February.
When I called the Congressmans office to get a quote about the brewing race, his assistant put me straight through to him. But Rangel said little of Conrad Muhammad beyond, "I dont know him." After some prodding, he allowed, "When he was with the mosque I saw him around, but since he left, I havent," and "I helped him try to get a job once, but that was by telephone." The Congressman concluded our awkward call by saying, "Theres no indication that hes going to run against me or anyone else. So it would be premature for me to make any comments about non-candidates."
I relayed the conversation to Muhammad, who was shocked.
"Are you serious?" he asked. "Its somewhat baffling If he doesnt know me hes not doing his job in the district. But he does know me, and hes being dishonest with the voters. Its insincere and disingenuous. The community of Harlem will not buy that. Its the wrong approach to a race that the district wants to see.
"This is Harlem," Muhammad concluded, "and we let the chips fall where they may."