Best Neighborhood Pet Store

Pet Central offers a wide variety of treats and toys, plus health and organic food option
by anne kristoff

Because you want the very best for your furry and feathered friends

Beasty Feast
327 West 14th St.
This place is immaculate. No wonder one customer calls it “Pet nirvana!” Beasty Feast carries a wide variety of food, treats, supplements, toys, grooming supplies and apparel, often beating prices and selection on the internet. While the main focus may seem to be on dogs, cat lovers herald the selection of unique litter boxes, bowls and a treat that one called “creamy kitty crack.”

Calling All Pets
1590 York Ave.
Calling All Pets has been a family-owned and operated pet store for over 20 years. They sell winter and rain coats, handmade sweaters, seasonal treats, holiday gifts and more. Regulars like French bulldog Gus visit every day and “is always ready for a treat and a pat!” For those who can't make it to the store, they also offer delivery service.

Pet Central
2643 Broadway
Pet Central started in 1999 with one store downtown. Now the family-owned outfit has multiple locations around the city. A fave of both owners and pets, the store carries a wide variety of treats and toys, as well as healthy and organic food options. Customers love that the store is clean and well-organized and that the staff is always helpful and friendly. In addition, Pet Central delivers anywhere in Manhattan and has a rewards program.