Home » Articles » Film » Films Reviews »  The Girl on the Train
Monday, March 9,2009

The Girl on the Train

France's most fascinating contemporary filmmaker, André Téchiné, exhibits his expansive abilities

By Armond White
. . . . . . .

The Girl on the Train
Directed by André Téchiné
At FSLC, Walter Reade Theater, March 10: 3:30 pm &  9:10 pm

A highlight of this year’s Rendezvous with French Cinema program at Lincoln Center is André Téchiné’s newest film The Girl on the Train, a combination topical expose and sophisticated melodrama. Using a real-life case where Alice (Emilie Dequenne), a girl from a banlieu outside Paris lied about being the victim of a bias attack, Téchiné takes the emotional pulse of hate crimes and finds symptoms of common psychological distress. In other words, it’s a love story from the uniquely expansive—and inquiring—point of view that makes Téchiné France’s most fascinating contemporary filmmaker.

The first sight of Alice rollerskating through the streets, thick curly hair surrounding her stolid face, presents a “normal” Téchiné youth—complex, enigmatic, hypersensitive to the world. Alice’s place in the universe, and her politically incorrect actions, recall the troubled boy in the 1987 Scene of the Crime where Téchiné evoked the template of Great Expectations to explore how one character’s fortune linked to and revealed a larger, social view of destiny.

Pondering Alice’s emotional life when she falls in love with a young wrestler, Franck (Nicolas Duvauchelle), takes Techine beneath the surface stability of other characters. Alice’s mother Louise (Catherine Deneuve) was a nonconformist now settled by maternity and unsettled by encountering an old acquaintance, Jewish activist Samuel Bleistein (Michel Blanc). Techine intermixes these histories and on-going fates; his quick, graceful pace, piercing insight and visual flair are perfectly symbolized in Alice’s rollerskating sprees. One is constantly propelled and dazzled.

Alice’s heterosexual female story keeps Téchiné several leaps ahead of one’s expectations—and especially the intellectualized gay-ghetto preoccupations of his sex-and-psychology protégé Jacques Nolot (Before I Forget, Porn Theatre).

The contrasts between Alice and Louise, Bleistein and Franck vividly illustrate the common effort to achieve satisfaction and strength. For Téchiné, race, class and gender give access to understanding this constant struggle. His post-modern approach, through Dickens, Lean, even the Dardennes brothers (Dequennes is best known for their film Rosetta) remains unsentimental about obdurate human nature. And for those further intrigued by these mysteries of love and character and society—and their authenticity—an honorary soundtrack to the emotions Téchiné uncovers in The Girl on the Train can also be found in every track of Morrissey’s Years of Refusal.

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Posted at 12/15/2009 
 
What, no blistering - no, blithering - tirades about the irrelevancy of Mr. White? No 99 to 600 comments defaming and correcting Mr. White's "attention seeking"? Wow. I'm shocked. Or could it be that he has simply given a good review to a film that NOBODY WHO WRITES THOSE COMMENTS GIVES A SHIT ABOUT??? Armond White differs with the fanboys on what constitutes great trash. That is not a flaw. But when he praises great art, nobody seems to care. This is what makes his detractors blithering imbeciles who clearly do not understand most of what he is saying. When he describes certain movies as "nihilistic", "narcissistic" and "solipsistic", he is using those words in context. It fascinates me that one of the biggest accusations against him is that he looks these words up for their definition before using them. Just putting this out there, but do you think maybe the reason people like to say this is because they do not know what the word means themselves? Just an idea. Aw, hell, I could go on here, but hey, nobody's going to read this anyway, so why should I give a shit? Take the time to read the review before you comment, people. And if you don't understand what he's saying, just admit it. Be an adult.

 

 
 


  • Wed
    17
  • Thu
    18
  • Fri
    19
  • Sat
    20
  • Sun
    21
  • Mon
    22
  • Tue
    23

Search in Events

Sign up for the NYPress
e-newsletter for weekly updates
and exciting event info:





Join us on Facebook Follow Us
on Twitter







 User Profile (click to open)



New_York_300_60.gif

 
 
Close
Close