Home » Articles » Film » Films Reviews »  DVD Review: Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
Wednesday, September 30,2009

DVD Review: Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

By Armond White
. . . . . . .

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

Walt Disney (DVD)

When Walt Disney’s Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs won the New York Film Critics Circle Award in 1937 (followed by an honorary Oscar) it announced a milestone in motion picture animation. The immensely popular film also became immensely influential, which is something that cannot be claimed for the routinely praised animated films of our era such as The Lion King, Finding Nemo and Wall-E. Remember how Roger Ebert rang the heavens for Beauty and the Beast? Snow White’s significance holds up well in Disney’s newly—vividly—restored new DVD.

And though this classic is often dramatically inert, its artful stylization remains impressive. Instead of compartmentalizing Disney’s signature animated features (the three masterworks Fantasia, Pinocchio and Dumbo) as an outmoded approach, Snow White brings back the beginning of a classical style and the reason why it mattered. On the DVD commentary, animator John Canemaker pays homage by comparing the film to Birth of a Nation and then Citizen Kane “for staging ideas” (Canemaker doesn’t say, but he surely means the presentation of Xanadu) and the programming of musical numbers and fantasy in The Wizard of Oz.

More precisely, Snow White set the template for animating universal fantasy, the western visionary heritage. This would even apply to such Japanese animation as Miyazaki but Snow White shows the reason people rarely go back to those films. Here is the foundation of how the modern world mentally interpreted those old folktales. It isn’t simply that Disney dominated the animation mainstream; his house-style of figuration and his formula for style was a translation of the Brothers Grim. (The Little Mermaid was a bowdlerization of Hans Christian Andersen.)

Chief artist Hamilton Luske explained the rule: “Our [humans] uninteresting progression from one situation to another must be skipped. We want to make things more interesting than ordinary life. So the characters flow—dreamlike. This works best with non-human figures—as in the dwarf caricatures, the evil queen but especially the animals.” It’s the human Snow White who is so chinless, neck-less and amorphous that her “goodness” is off-putting. And the Prince also moves like a zombie. This proves it’s not the Ideal that Disney animation perfects but the opposite—the stylized vision.

Snow White triumphantly established the way film could visualize the imagination—as when trees and frogs metamorphose into crocodiles, ghouls and skeletons. Lavish details of nature, woodland creatures proceed from the animal spiritual metaphors of Griffith’s silent era into ecstatic symbolism. Note the bluebird singing to Snow White in the house cleaning sequence—a vision that eventually influenced Happy Feet but was also distorted into ugly absurdity in Disney’s own Enchantment. Obviously, these lessons need to be relearned.

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Posted at 10/19/2009 
 
Interested in the NEW book by Armond White? It's called, "KEEP MOVING: The Michael Jackson Chronicles" and it's a collection of essays on the subject of King Of Pop, MICHAEL JACKSON. Written over the course of 25 years, the essays focus on the songs and music videos AFTER the Thriller album. If you are interested in more information, google the title OR visit the blog www.resistanceworks.blogspot.com

 

Posted at 10/01/2009 
 
Mr. White, I agree with a majority of your review. However, I must point out one factual error -- the cardinal sin of your profession. The Disney movie that you criticize in your final graf is called "Enchanted" (Lima, 2007), starring the delightful Amy Adams. I understand you did not enjoy this picture, but I think it at least deserves to be called by the correct title.

 

Posted at 09/30/2009 
 
As a budding animation fan, I rediscovered Snow White during its 1995 theatrical re-release. Sorry, Armond, but it doesn't hold up. The only things really memorable about it are the jarring tonal shifts. (Remember how that corny "nightmare forest" sequence turned on a dime into a musical interlude where Snow White starts signing to animals? Would you consider this finely honed storytelling?) It's almost quaint to view now, in the Ghibli-and-Pixar era. In the best Ghibli and Pixar films, the emotions are more genuine, the fantasy is more fully realized, and the staging of the performances isn't as mannered as Snow White. Were it not for nostalgia, it would be hard for anyone over the age of 10 to get excited about this. Snow White made the animated feature film possible, but it's a dated technical exercise now. I only watch it for academic reasons. --mrman

 

 
 


  • Sat
    21
  • Sun
    22
  • Mon
    23
  • Tue
    24
  • Wed
    25
  • Thu
    26
  • Fri
    27

Search in Events

Sign up for the NYPress
e-newsletter for weekly updates
and exciting event info:





Join us on Facebook Follow Us
on Twitter








 User Profile (click to open)



New_York_300_60.gif

 
 
Close
Close