You are in: Home » Blogs » Staff Blogs
. . . . . . .
 
Aug
21

'Tintin' Deemed Racist, Removed From Shelves

In Section: NY comPRESSed » Posted In: Politics, Art, Brooklyn, Culture, Legal Posted By: Will Alden
- A banned book in Brooklyn, New York City, NY, USA? In a move that pushes us closer to totalitarianism, Brooklyn's chief librarian condemned 'Tintin Au Congo,' one book in the nearly 80-year-old series by Georges (Herge) Remi, the Daily News reports.

After a reader complained that it was "racially offensive," library authorities decided the book depicted Africans as "monkeys" and chose to remove it from library shelves. It is now locked behind secret doors in Brooklyn's central library and can be viewed only by appointment.

While it's true that Herge's work seems to promote an imperialist and racist attitude towards African people, what's more offensive is that librarians don't think readers are mature enough to understand the racism as a product of its time. The Tintin books are beloved classics, and their racist elements can in fact be instructive. The News quotes Brooklyn resident Karina Estedan, who supports the ban, as saying, "The public library caters to the sensitivity of the community. People are trying to erase the mistakes of the past." Those "mistakes" are still alive in the present, and erasing their documentation dooms us to repeat them.

It's no secret that classic—and modern—works of literature depict and even condone offensive attitudes. The Odyssey, that greatest of great texts, supports a misogynistic attitude. Even Sixteen Candles, the John Hughes classic, portrays an Asian exchange student in an extremely and relentlessly racist manner. Banning one book isn't going to solve anything.
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Posted at 08/21/2009 
 
Well put! Hergé was a fascist sympathizer and this work is unquestionably racist. That doesn't mean that the library needs to be seen as condoning his attitudes by having the book on its shelves. Would we be protected from fascism by being unable to read "Mein Kampf"? On the contrary. Knowledge is power, and denying the past doesn't change the present. As Louis Brandeis said, "Sunlight is the best disinfectant."

 

 
 


  • Mon
    23
  • Tue
    24
  • Wed
    25
  • Thu
    26
  • Fri
    27
  • Sat
    28
  • Sun
    29

Search in Events

Sign up for the NYPress
e-newsletter for weekly updates
and exciting event info:





Join us on Facebook Follow Us
on Twitter








 User Profile (click to open)



New_York_300_60.gif

 
 
Close
Close